- Home
- Stocks
- TATAMOTORS
- TATAMOTORS Price Target
TATAMOTORS
401234567894012345678950123456789.4012345678950123456789
+0.65 (+0.15%)
NSE Volume
130.7L+
Broker Reports
BUY
BUY
SELL
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
SELL
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
SELL
BUY
BUY
SELL
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
REDUCE
BUY
BUY
REDUCE
BUY
BUY
REDUCE
BUY
REDUCE
BUY
BUY
HOLD
HOLD
For TML we build 4.5% sales CAGR in FY20P-22E, with FY22E profit of Rs 2,848 crore. While TML’s cost, cash flow focus is encouraging, pace of demand recovery remains an unknown. We await green shoots of revival before turning decisively positive. We value TML at Rs 115 on SOTP basis i.e. 10x & 3.5x EV/EBITDA (FY22E) to TML standalone business & JLR, respectively, retaining our HOLD rating on the stock.
BUY
“While the COVID-19 pandemic continues to impact the global Auto industry, we are pleased to see initial green shoots of recovery. We are working alongside our retailers, planning for gradual recovery as lockdowns relax and economies respond. Through the quarter, we continued to introduce new and updated Jaguar and Land Rover vehicles to very positive response.” The stock trades at 2.7x FY22 EV/EBITDA and 0.7x P/BV. Maintain Buy, with TP of ~INR126 (Jun’22-based SOTP).
BUY
Mr Felix Brautigam, Jaguar Land Rover Chief Commercial Officer said, “The automotive trading environment remains challenging globally. Against this background, it is all the more encouraging to see our China turnaround strategy and work with the local retailer network generating positive results as sales have improved in China for the fourth consecutive month. Land Rover year-on-year global growth continues; with the latest generation of our ever-popular luxury compact Range Rover Evoque now available in all regions. Sales of the comprehensively updated best-selling Land Rover Discovery Sport are ramping up well. The Range Rover Sport, also remains a key performer, with particularly strong sales in North America and China. For Jaguar, the recently-updated Jaguar XE continues to receive critical acclaim and we are seeing an ongoing strong response to our award-winning I-PACE, the all-electric performance SUV that puts Jaguar at the forefront of the electric vehicle revolution.” The stock trades at 13.9x FY21E consol. EPS and 0.9x P/B. Maintain Buy with a target price of INR185 (Sep’21 SOTP-based).
BUY
Over the last three years, JLR has suffered from an adverse product/market mix and higher capex, resulting in negative FCFF over FY18-20. JLR has been focused on cutting capex/cost, benefits of which have started to reflect now. Finally, the mix is normalizing with a recovery in LR and China. On the other hand, India business appears to have bottomed out in 2QFY20, although a full-blown recovery may be a few quarters away. Hence, we had recently upgraded the stock to Buy as it offers a favorable risk-reward. Our target price stands at ~INR195.
BUY
Mr Felix Brautigam, Jaguar Land Rover Chief Commercial Officer said, “Against the backdrop of a downturn in the global automotive market, we were pleased to see our sales grow in the US and China. Despite the ongoing headwinds in China, we continue to see green shoots of recovery in our sales there. The intensive work with our retailers in the region, combined with Significant process and product improvements are starting to gain traction. For Jaguar globally, we were very excited to launch our new Jaguar F-TYPE at the beginning of December, to initial very positive customer and media reaction. Land Rover continues to perform well overall, with a very rich mix of models. Sales of our comprehensively updated Land Rover Discovery Sport are also gathering momentum while appreciation of the all-new Range Rover Evoque is growing apace as customers opt for its combination of dynamic on- road handling, luxurious refinement and trademark Land Rover all-terrain capability.” The stock trades at 13.7x FY21E consol. EPS and 0.8x P/B. Maintain Buy with a target price of INR195 (Sep’21 SOTP-based).
REDUCE
HOLD
Going forward, we expect the topline and EBITDA to grow at a CAGR of 0.6% & 13.1%, respectively, in FY19-21E. We believe TML would not turn FCF positive before FY21E, with our outlook clouded by tough business conditions globally and in India. Using SOTP valuation technique, we value TML at | 175 i.e. 10x & 4x EV/EBITDA (FY21E) to TML standalone business & JLR, respectively. We maintain our HOLD rating. We are enthused by incremental capital commitment by Tata Sons (~| 6,500 crore) and have incorporated it in our numbers. We believe it will help limit the company’sleverage, going forward. The Q2FY20 performance showed substantial promise but we await sustained margin improvement and further cash flow visibility at JLR before revisiting our directional call on TML.
HOLD
With China stabilizing and expected to recover hereon and cost control benefits, the management has reiterated their EBIT guidance for full year FY20E at 3-4%. However, given 1HFY20 EBIT margins at 0.2%, along with Brexit uncertainties ahead, we feel this would be challenging. Standalone margins are expected to remain under pressure owing to the weakness in demand, uncertainties around pre-buy and increasing discounting, especially in the CV segment. We factor in 5.5% volume CAGR in FY19-22E for JLR with EBIT margins of ~5% by FY22E. We upgrade consol EPS by ~15% each for FY20/21 to factor in for JLR improvement. We maintain Hold with the target price of Rs138 (from Rs132), where we value JLR at 3x Sep’21E EV/EBITDAand Standalone entity at 8x Sep’21E EV/EBITDA.
NEUTRAL
A sustainable recovery in volumes at JLR, particularly for LR and China, along with the ongoing cost-cutting initiatives, is the key to value-accretive growth and stock performance. This is particularly important due to the downcycle in the cash-cow India CV business. The stock trades at 10.5x FY21E consolidated EPS and 0.6x P/B. Maintain Neutral with a target price of INR119 (Sep’21 SOTP-based).
NEUTRAL
A sustainable recovery in volumes in JLR, particularly in the profitable markets of China, along with the ongoing cost-cutting initiatives, is key to value- accretive growth and stock performance. This is particularly important due to the impending downcycle in the cash-cow India CV business in FY21. The stock trades at 13.3x/8.8x FY20/21E consol. EPS. Maintain Neutral with a target price of INR146 (Mar’21E SOTP-based).
HOLD
Going forward, we expect topline, EBITDA to grow at a CAGR of 5.1%, 19.5%, respectively, in FY19-21E. PAT is expected to be volatile given the nature of TML’s earnings that include a high degree of one-offs. Market conditions remain challenging globally and in India, clouding our outlook. Using SOTP valuation technique we value TML at Rs 160 i.e. 8x EV/EBITDA (FY21E) to TML standalone business (~15% premium to its competition) and 3x EV/EBITDA (FY21E) to JLR. We retain our HOLD rating on the stock.
HOLD
JLR tie-up with BMW, directionally correct… Valuation & Outlook: JLR witnessed demand concerns starting June 2018 amid uncertainty over Brexit, tariff barriers in China, a general auto slowdown in China among others. This led to a decline in sales, which continued until April 2019. Going forward, as the base effect kicks in from June 2019, we expect its performance to normalise from here on amid conscious efforts to reduce cash costs, improve brand perception, control working capital cycle and capex outgo. However, we await positive commentary from JLR on volume as well as cash costs savings perspective before any meaningful change in our stance. However, the present collaboration mitigates risks over cash flow burn at JLR on upcoming technologies over a longer timeframe. We stick to our HOLD rating on the stock with a target price of | 185.
ACCUMULATE
Standalone turnaround 2.0 delivering results. Tata Motors Investor day highlighted details about its medium-to-long term strategy (Turnaround 2.0) for the domestic business. With focus on topline growth, customer centricity, enhanced dealer engagement, agile cost management and a lean & accountable organization, the management reiterated their key objectives: 1) Outperforming the industry for both the CV & PV segment (CV & PV volumes for TTMT up 17.5% % 12% respectively for FY19) 2) EBIT margin target of 4-6% over FY20-22 and 5-7% in the long run (FY19 EBIT margins at 3.8%) 3) Higher FCF generation curtailing Subsidiary investments within affordable limits. While the domestic demand environment for the next 3-6 months is expected to remain muted, H2 should see some recovery on anticipated pre-buy ahead of BS VI implementation. JLR outlook remains muted both for volumes and profitability with cut in EBIT margin guidance over FY20-21E to 3-6% (earlier 4-6%) owing to continued demand challenges & model run-outs. Retain ‘’Accumulate’’ with a target price of Rs192, where we value JLR at 1.5x Mar’21E EV/EBITDA and Standalone entity at 9x Mar’21E EPS.
REDUCE
Outlook & Valuation: In view of the challenges in JLR business and ongoing slowdown in domestic operations, we tweak few of our estimates for FY20E/FY21E. In light of massive slowdown in JLR’s business, higher debt level and expected cash crunch, we maintain our REDUCE recommendation on the stock and retain our an SOTP-based Target Price of Rs135 (valuing the standalone business at Rs130, JLR at Rs222 and other subsidiaries at Rs22, based on FY21E EBITDA, post excluding net debt of Rs239/share).
HOLD
BUY
Volume outlook remains bleak Consolidated performance for Tata Motors over Q4FY19 surpassed our expectations, with JLR operating margins at 9.8% v/s our estimate of 8.8%. Standalone margins however, stood lower than expected at 7.3%, owing to high discounting in the industry. For full year FY19, JLR EBIT margins came in at -0.7% (Q4FY19 EBIT at 3%) and the management has again revised their EBIT guidance for FY20-21E downwards at 3-4% (earlier 3-6%) on account of demand challenges and run-out of their most selling models Range Rover & Range Rover sport. While dealer inventory levels have lowered in China, demand is yet to pick up, wherein some recovery is expected H2FY20 onwards. TTMT’s cost reduction efforts have been yielding results, however, volume uptick remains key. We currently factor in 5.8%/6.7% volume growth for JLR for FY20/21E respectively and downgrade to ‘’Accumulate’’ with the target price of Rs192, where we value JLR at 1.5x Mar’21E EV/EBITDA and Standalone entity at 9x Mar’21E EPS.
NEUTRAL
JLR in-line, S/A disappoints; guides for recovery in both businesses in FY20. Valuation view: We raise our consol. EPS estimate for FY20 by ~16% to factor in lower depreciation at JLR and higher other income in S/A. However, we note that the weakening outlook for the India business is fading the cost-cutting-led recovery at JLR. FY21 could be a tough year for India and JLR (run-out of most profitable RR/RR Sport). Further, the noise around EVs, Brexit and trade-war adds to the uncertainty. Hence, we maintain Neutral rating with a target price of INR199 (Mar’21 SOTP).
NEUTRAL
JLR’s Jan’19 wholesales below est. at 41.7k. The stock trades at 8.8x/7.2x FY20/FY21 consolidated EPS. Maintain Neutral with a target price of INR166 (Mar’21 SOTP-based).
BUY
BUY
JLR’s wholesale volumes decline in a challenging market. The stock trades at 8.3x FY20E consolidated EPS, 2.3x EV/EBITDA and 0.6x P/BV. Maintain Buy with a target price of INR246 (Dec’20E SOTP-based).
BUY
BUY
JLR’s Nov’18 wholesales in line at 49.3k units (-9% YoY) Jaguar volumes increase 23% YoY, while Land Rover declines 18.5% YoY. The stock trades at 7x FY20E consolidated EPS, 2.1x EV/EBITDA and 0.5x P/BV. Maintain Buy with a target price of INR246 (Sep-20 SOTP-based).
BUY
Operational challenges at JLR continue… With JLR reporting weak performance for this quarter again, with volumes down 14.7% YoY, EBIT margins at -0.7% & adj. PAT loss of GBP75mn, Tata Motors consolidated adjusted loss stood at Rs3.3bn, while standalone margins stood at a decent 8.5% and standalone adj. profit came in at Rs4.5bn. While Q3 is anticipated to remain muted, JLR is expected start recovering over Q4FY19, where the management expects full year FY19 to see flat volume growth and EBIT breakeven, on the back of higher seasonal sales and aggressive cost reduction efforts. Concerns over sales in China are expected to persist over the near term with dealer inventory in China for Chery JV currently at 2 months. Standalone performance for the company remains on track. We currently factor in ~6% volume growth for JLR over FY19-20 and maintain “BUY” with the target price of Rs267, where we value JLR at 2x Mar’20E EV/EBITDA and Standalone entity at 9x Mar’20 EPS.
BUY
JLR’s wholesale of 53k units (-8% YoY) exceeds estimate Jaguar volumes up 9% YoY, but Land Rover volumes decline 19% YoY. The stock trades at 9.1/5.3x FY19E/20E consolidated EPS. Maintain Buy with a target price of INR335 (Sep-20 SOTP-based).
HOLD
Challenging times continue at JLR… Negative FCF; subdued return ratios; retain HOLD! JLR is investing aggressively in technologies amid an uncertain business outlook, thereby generating negative free cash flows & stressing its balance sheet. This is likely to result in muted return ratios with RoCE<10%. Going forward, revising our estimates, on consolidated basis, over FY18-20E we expect sales to grow at a CAGR of 5.9%. On the margins front, we expect ~140 bps contraction in EBITDA margins with a consequent drop in PAT over FY18-20E. We revise our target price to | 200/share on SOTP basis and maintain our HOLD rating on the stock. The only saviour for TML is the up trending domestic segment wherein the company is witnessing robust prospects both in the M&HCV space as well as PV segment.
BUY
JLR’s Aug-2018 wholesale above estimate at 42.7k units Jaguar +29.4% YoY (+14.3% MoM), while Land Rover -14.9% YoY (+26% MoM). The stock trades at 9.2/7.2x FY19E/20E consolidated EPS. Maintain Buy with a target price of INR353 (September-2020 SOTP-based).
BUY
BUY
HOLD
BUY
HOLD
HOLD
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
HOLD
BUY
HOLD
ACCUMULATE
HOLD
BUY
BUY
HOLD
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
ACCUMULATE
BUY
BUY
HOLD
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
HOLD
ACCUMULATE
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
HOLD
BUY
HOLD
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
HOLD
BUY
BUY
BUY
HOLD
BUY
BUY
BUY
HOLD
BUY
BUY
HOLD
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
ACCUMULATE
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
HOLD
BUY
NEUTRAL
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
BUY
About
Tata Motors Ltd.
NSE: TATAMOTORS | BSE: 500570 | ISIN: INE155A01022 | Sector: Auto
Create your account on Frontpage
Join 2,00,000 Indian traders and discuss trades, strategies, news & views on any stock.