FrontPageTeam,
please look at how you calculate Reputation of Experts. You may please include Paper Trades there, and then based on various accurate and reliable metrics, you will be able to calculate a reliable Reputation Score for all experts.

It may not matter if someone shares interesting or popular posts - but it matters of someone is clocking very high profits, with very less risks and a small period of time.
(so, you can include profit %, SL used, win ratio, size of profits/losses, no of trades, account size, etc.) (account size may not matter for paper trades, so you can use judgement while applying these)
Make FrontPage Amazing! - 4650232